Anastasia Brow Wiz Review: Why It's Still My Ride-or-Die After 5 Years

Let me paint you a picture: It's 2018. I'm standing in Sephora, staring at a $25 brow pencil like it's made of gold. "Who pays this much for eyebrows?" I muttered. Fast forward to today - I'm on my 14th Brow Wiz. That's $350 worth of eyebrow pencils, people. Was it worth it? Let's get into the messy, wonderful truth about this cult-favorite.

What Makes Brow Wiz Different From Drugstore Dupes

After testing 22 (!) brow pencils (yes, I have a problem), here's what sets the Anastasia Brow Wiz apart:

The tip: That 0.9mm micro-pencil is magic for drawing individual brow hairs
The formula: Waxy enough to stay put, but soft enough to never tug
The spoolie: The best in the game - doesn't shed like cheaper versions

Funny story: I once tried to "dupe" it with a $5 drugstore pencil. My best friend took one look and said, "What happened to your face?" Never again.

The Shade Matching Dilemma (Solved)

With 11 shades, finding your match can be overwhelming. After some... questionable choices (RIP my 2019 orange brow phase), here's what works:

Blondes: "Taupe" is perfect for cool tones, "Medium Brown" for warm
Brunettes: "Soft Brown" is the universal flatterer
Black brows: "Ebony" has the right blue-black undertone

Pro tip from an Anastasia counter artist: Go one shade lighter than you think you need. The pigment builds beautifully.

Application Tricks I Learned the Hard Way

It took me six months to stop drawing sperm brows (you know what I mean). These techniques saved me:

The Feather Method: Flick upwards at a 45° angle for natural hairs
Less Is More: Start with just filling sparse spots, not the whole brow
Spoolie Therapy: Brush through every 2-3 strokes to soften

My "aha" moment? Realizing the pencil works best when held like a paintbrush, not like you're writing an exam.

How It Compares to Other Luxury Brow Pencils

After side-by-side testing with 7 competitors (my bathroom looks like a makeup counter), here's the breakdown:

Product	Price	Brow Wiz Wins At
Benefit Precisely My Brow	$24	More natural finish, better shade range
Hourglass Arch Brow	$34	Precision application, better for fine lines
Makeup By Mario	$22	Longer wear time, less smudging

Shocking discovery? In blind tests, 8/10 friends preferred my brows done with Brow Wiz over the $34 option. That's saying something.

The One Downside No One Talks About

That tiny amount of product? It goes fast if you're not careful. Here's how I make mine last:

Store it sideways: Prevents tip breakage (learned after losing 3 to bathroom drops)
Use with powder: Extends wear so you use less product
Buy during sales: Sephora's VIB sale is my twice-yearly stock-up

Truth be told? At my current skill level, one lasts me 3 months with daily use. Not terrible, but not great.

Is It Worth $25? My Brutally Honest Take

Let's break it down like I did at 3AM when justifying my 5th repurchase:

Worth it if: You crave natural-looking brows or have sparse areas to fill
Not worth it if: You're a makeup minimalist or prefer fluffy brows
Pro tip: The dual-ended design means you're getting two tools in one

Final confession? I've hidden my backup Brow Wiz from my sister. Twice. That's loyalty.

How to Spot a Fake (Because Yes, They Exist)

After accidentally buying a counterfeit on Amazon (never again), here's how to tell:

Packaging: Real ones have crisp, stamped letters - no blurry text
Smell: Authentic has a light wax scent, fakes smell chemical
Spoolie: Genuine ones have tightly wound bristles that never shed

My rule? Only buy from Sephora, Ulta, or the Anastasia website. That $5 "deal" isn't worth the risk.

The Verdict: Who Should (And Shouldn't) Buy It

After all this testing, here's my parting wisdom:

Buy if: You want salon-quality brows at home or have fine hairs to define
Skip if: You prefer a bold, laminated brow look
Try first: Get a sample at Sephora before committing

Would I repurchase? I've got two in my purse right now. Some love stories never end.

Updated Posts

Saturday, July 12, 2025